Over a Century of Leaving Well Enough Alone

  • headerhistory

In 1839, Fanny Kemble, wife of Little St. Simons Island’s then-owner, Pierce Butler II, visited the Island and called it “a forest in the sea” and a “tangled wilderness.” Were she to visit today she might well be pleased to discover just how little things have changed on Little St. Simons Island and how apt her characterizations– made some 169 years ago–remain.

In 2008, the Island observed its 100th Anniversary–a celebration of one remarkable family’s abiding devotion to letting nature reign and to simply leaving well enough wonderfully alone. Yet this most recent century of the Island’s history is but a sliver of the stories, sagas and adventures that have swept across its 10,000 acres.

From Native Americans To Plantation Days

Around 700 A.D., Native Americans, known as Guale Indians, populated the coast of Georgia. Along with its abundant fish and game, Little St. Simons Island’s bountiful oyster beds drew the Guale to the Island seasonally. Large piles of discarded oyster shells, called middens, can be found near the northern end of Little St. Simons Island and are among the Island’s most historic sites.

As he sails up the Georgia coast in 1562, French explorer Jean Ribeaut encounters two islands, one smaller than the other, and (according to some historians) names them after St. Simeon, a small town east of Paris. The two islands, Great St. Simon’s Island and Little St. Simon’s Island (with apostrophes that have long since vanished) first appear with these names on maps in the 18th century.

In 1760, Samuel Augspourger, a Swiss colonist living in South Carolina, became Little St. Simons Island’s first private owner of record. In 1768, he sold the Island to his grandson, Gabriel Manigault.
Along with sizable parts of coastal Georgia, Major Pierce Butler acquired Little St. Simons Island in 1774. The Island became part of Butler’s vast, coastal rice and cotton cultivation operations centered just across the Hampton River at Hampton Plantation on St. Simons Island. A stretch of 500 acres of marshlands at Little St. Simons Island’s northwestern tip was drained, placed under cultivation with sea island cotton and called Five Pound Plantation.

Major Butler’s grandson, Pierce Butler II, assumed ownership of Little St. Simons Island in 1836. Butler’s
wife, Fanny Kemble, was an English actress and the author of several published journals including the famous Journal of a Residence on a Georgian Plantation that vividly recounted the often harsh realities of life on the antebellum coast.

Cedars Are Sighted and an Island Is Saved

While on a fishing trip to the Georgia coast in 1907, O.F. Chichester, of the Eagle Pencil Company of New York City, spied the Island’s abundance of red cedar trees–ideal for pencil making. He reported his find to Company owner, Philip Berolzheimer.

On January 16, 1908, Little St. Simons Island was purchased by the Company from Pierce Butler’s descendant, Frances Butler Leigh. Though the cedar trees were found to generally be too wind-bent for pencil making, Philip Berolzheimer fell in love with the Island’s beauty and purchased it from his Company as a private retreat for family and friends. Mr. Berolzheimer’s devotion to the Island’s preservation founded a century of environmental stewardship and protective practices that continues today and in perpetuity.

Bandits Arrive

In 1921, Philip Berolzheimer, along with seven friends that included some of New York City’s most prominent policy-makers, journeyed from New York to his beloved Little St. Simons Island. Known affectionately as the “Eight Bandits,” the group would make many such sojourns, spending weeks here fishing, hunting, playing parlor games and enjoying each other’s company. The flag they created to commemorate their group depicted eight ducks in flight above a running deer. A slightly modified version of this flag serves as the Island’s present-day logo.

Down Through the Years

Upon Philip Berolzheimer’s death in 1942, ownership of the Island passed to his children, Charles and Helen Berolzheimer. In turn, their children–Philip, Michael, Helen and Ransom– steadfastly continued the family’s legacy of love for and preservation of Little St. Simons Island.

Welcoming The Public To a Private Island

In 1979, a new era began as The Lodge on Little St. Simons Island opened to the public, welcomed its first overnight guests and gently, carefully entered the tourism industry that prevails across Georgia’s fabled Golden Isles. Through policies that strictly limit the number of overnight and day-trip visitors and which guard the Island’s natural beauty, guests are able to experience the same simple charms and rare wonders that originally enthralled and captivated Philip Berolzheimer.
Over the nearly three decades since opening to the public, the Island has remained under the watchful eye of still deeply-involved Berolzheimer family members. This nurturing has led to Little St. Simons Island achieving a perfect balance between preserving this unchanged natural sanctuary and providing thoughtful enhancements to the experience for those who visit here.
As a result, Little St. Simons Island has secured its place among the world’s most unique and cherished retreats.

A Unique Experience

Little St. Simons Island is more than an island. It is an experience. This small, quaint and relaxed resort offers guests something that is eloquently unlike anything anywhere else. The Island’s owners and management want history and nature to imperceptibly envelop visitors, putting them pleasantly in touch with all its historical eras and natural wonders.
In a letter of July 9, 1968 to Dr. Vernon J. Henry, Jr., of the National Science Foundation in Washington, D.C., Charles Berolzheimer wrote: "I have long believed, as my father did, that Little St. Simons Island should be preserved and not destroyed by either industrial or tourist activities."
The descendants of Philip Berolzheimer have made this belief a reality for everyone who steps ashore on Little St. Simons Island, Georgia.